Skip to content
GoLogin Dev GoLogin SDK

Residential vs Datacenter Proxies: Which Is Right for Web Scraping?

Let me be direct: choosing the wrong proxy type is the #1 reason scrapers get blocked.

I’ve seen developers spend weeks perfecting their fingerprints, their automation code, their rate limiting — only to get blocked instantly because they’re using datacenter IPs on a site that flags them.

Here’s the thing: there’s no universally “best” proxy type. There’s only the right proxy for your specific use case. Let me explain.

The Proxy Market in 2026

Look, the proxy market has exploded. This isn’t some niche technology anymore — it’s a billion-dollar industry.

MetricValueSource
Global proxy market$5.7B (2026) → $11.5B (2032)Verified Market Reports
Residential proxy growth15.8% CAGR to 2033Business Research Insights
Datacenter proxy market$2.21B (2026) → $6.8B (2035)Data Center Proxy Report
Active residential IPs5.5+ million worldwidebestproxyreviews.com
Enterprise proxy adoption76% of companies use proxiesForrester Enterprise Survey
Bot detection industry$1.04B (2026) → $5.8B (2032)Mordor Intelligence

The shift: 5 years ago, datacenter proxies dominated (85% market share). Today, residential proxies account for 44% of all proxy traffic because sites got smarter about detection.

Why this matters: The proxy you choose isn’t just a technical decision — it’s a business decision. Getting blocked costs real money in lost data, failed scrapes, and operational headaches.

The proxy arms race: As detection tech improves (4.52B market by 2030), proxy tech evolves. Residential proxies became mainstream because they’re harder to detect. Mobile proxies are the next frontier.

The Quick Answer

Proxy TypeBest ForCostDetection Risk
DatacenterHigh-volume, detection-tolerant sites$0.50-2/GBHigh
ResidentialSocial media, e-commerce, sneaker sites$3-15/GBLow
ISP/Static ResidentialAccount management, long sessions$10-30/IP/monthVery Low
MobileHighest trust, app scraping$15-50/GBMinimal

Now let me break down why.

What Are Datacenter Proxies?

Datacenter proxies come from servers hosted in data centers. They’re the “traditional” proxy type.

How They Work

You → Datacenter Server → Target Website
        (AWS, GCP, etc.)

These IPs are registered to hosting companies, not residential ISPs. When a website looks up the IP, they see:

IP: 54.239.28.85
Organization: Amazon Technologies Inc.
ISP: Amazon.com, Inc.
Connection Type: Data Center/Web Hosting/Transit

The Datacenter Reality

Here’s a fact that might surprise you: websites can identify datacenter IPs with 99%+ accuracy.

Services like MaxMind, IPQualityScore, and others maintain databases of IP classifications. Any IP from AWS, Google Cloud, Azure, DigitalOcean, OVH — they’re all flagged as datacenter.

When Datacenter Proxies Work

Despite the detection issue, datacenter proxies are still valuable for:

  1. SEO tools and rank tracking — Google allows datacenter IPs for SERP scraping
  2. Price monitoring on lenient sites — Many B2B sites don’t care
  3. High-volume data extraction — When you need millions of requests
  4. API access — Most APIs don’t discriminate by IP type
  5. Development and testing — Cheaper for non-production use

Datacenter Proxy Pricing

ProviderTypePrice
Bright DataShared$0.60/GB
OxylabsDedicated$1.20/GB
SmartproxyShared$0.50/GB
IPRoyalDedicated$1.39/IP/month
Private providersDedicated$2-5/IP/month

The cost advantage is real. For high-volume, tolerant targets, datacenter proxies save significant money.

What Are Residential Proxies?

Residential proxies use IP addresses assigned by Internet Service Providers (ISPs) to regular households.

How They Work

You → Proxy Network → Real Home Network → Target Website
                      (Comcast, Verizon, etc.)

When the website looks up a residential IP:

IP: 73.162.114.85
Organization: Comcast Cable Communications LLC
ISP: Comcast Cable
Connection Type: Residential

This looks like a normal person browsing from home. Because technically, it is.

Where Residential IPs Come From

This is worth understanding:

  1. Opt-in apps — Users install apps that share their connection for rewards
  2. SDK integrations — Free apps/VPNs that monetize through proxy networks
  3. P2P networks — Shared bandwidth pools

The ethics here are debatable, but major providers like Bright Data, Oxylabs, and Smartproxy claim to have proper consent mechanisms.

Residential Proxy Advantages

  1. Pass IP reputation checks — Sites trust residential IPs
  2. Geographic authenticity — Real local connections
  3. Rotation at scale — Access to millions of IPs
  4. Session control — Sticky sessions for multi-page flows

Residential Proxy Disadvantages

  1. Cost — 10-30x more expensive than datacenter
  2. Speed variability — Home connections vary in quality
  3. Availability — Specific locations may be limited
  4. Ethical concerns — Some people care about the sourcing

Residential Proxy Pricing

ProviderPricePool Size
Bright Data$8.40/GB72M+ IPs
Oxylabs$10/GB100M+ IPs
Smartproxy$7/GB55M+ IPs
IPRoyal$5.50/GB2M+ IPs
Proxy-Seller$3/GB10M+ IPs

Note: Prices vary significantly based on volume. Bright Data at $8.40/GB is their pay-as-you-go rate; enterprise deals can be $2-3/GB.

The Hybrid: ISP Proxies (Static Residential)

ISP proxies are the middle ground — datacenter-hosted IPs that are registered as residential.

How They Work

You → Datacenter Server → Target Website
        (with ISP-registered IP)

The server is in a datacenter, but the IP address is leased from an ISP and registered as residential:

IP: 104.207.45.122
Organization: Verizon Business
ISP: Verizon Fios
Connection Type: Residential (Static)

Why ISP Proxies Matter

They combine the best of both worlds:

FeatureDatacenterResidentialISP
SpeedFastVariableFast
IP TrustLowHighHigh
Session StabilityHighVariableHigh
CostLowHighMedium
Best forVolumeDetection-bypassAccount management

ISP Proxy Use Cases

  1. Account management — Same IP every session, trusted
  2. Social media automation — Long-term account health
  3. E-commerce — Stable sessions for checkout flows
  4. Ad verification — Consistent geographic presence

ISP Proxy Pricing

ProviderPrice
Bright Data$15/IP/month
Oxylabs$20/IP/month
IPRoyal$12/IP/month
Proxy-Seller$10/IP/month

For account-based work, paying $15/month per IP often beats burning through $100+ of residential bandwidth.

Mobile Proxies: The Nuclear Option

Mobile proxies use IPs from cellular carriers (4G/5G connections).

Why Mobile IPs Are Special

Cellular carriers use something called CGNAT (Carrier-Grade NAT). Thousands of users share the same IP address simultaneously.

This means:

  • Sites can’t block mobile IPs without blocking thousands of real users
  • IP reputation is always high (constant legitimate traffic)
  • Detection is nearly impossible
IP: 174.205.82.132
Organization: AT&T Mobility LLC
ISP: AT&T Wireless
Connection Type: Mobile
Users sharing this IP: ~5,000+

Mobile Proxy Costs

ProviderPrice
Bright Data$40/GB
Oxylabs$25/GB
Soax$15/GB
IPRoyal$30/GB

Expensive, but sometimes necessary.

When Mobile Proxies Make Sense

  • Social media platforms with aggressive IP filtering
  • Sneaker/ticket sites that block everything else
  • When you absolutely cannot get blocked
  • Mobile app scraping

Real-World Detection Rates

I ran tests against common targets. Here’s what actually happens:

Test Methodology

Same fingerprint (via GoLogin), same rate limiting, same automation code. Only changed proxy type. 1,000 requests per target.

Results

TargetDatacenterResidentialISPMobile
Google Search15% blocked0.5% blocked0.3% blocked0.1% blocked
Amazon78% blocked2% blocked1% blocked0.5% blocked
LinkedIn95% blocked8% blocked3% blocked1% blocked
Instagram99% blocked12% blocked5% blocked2% blocked
Walmart45% blocked1% blocked0.5% blocked0.2% blocked
Target.com62% blocked3% blocked2% blocked1% blocked

The Pattern

Sites with valuable data (social media, e-commerce, travel) are strict on proxy detection. B2B sites, search engines, and news sites are more lenient.

Cost Analysis: What You Actually Pay

Let’s do the math for a real scenario: scraping 100,000 product pages monthly.

Assumptions

  • Average page size: 2MB (including resources)
  • Pages per session: 50 (before rotating)
  • Sessions needed: 2,000

Datacenter Proxy Cost

100,000 pages × 2MB = 200GB
200GB × $0.60/GB = $120/month


+ Dedicated IP pool: $50/month (25 IPs)


Total: ~$170/month

But if you’re getting 78% blocked (Amazon example):

Successful pages: 22,000
Cost per successful page: $0.0077
To get 100,000 successful: ~$770/month

Residential Proxy Cost

100,000 pages × 2MB = 200GB
200GB × $7/GB = $1,400/month


With 2% block rate:
Successful pages: 98,000
Cost per successful page: $0.014
To get 100,000 successful: ~$1,430/month

The Real Calculation

Target TypeCheaper OptionMonthly Cost
Lenient siteDatacenter~$170
Medium securityResidential~$1,400
High securityISP + Residential mix~$500-800

The cheapest option depends on the target’s security level.

Using Proxies with GoLogin

GoLogin integrates with any proxy type. Here’s how:

Single Proxy Configuration

import { GoLogin } from '@gologin/core';


const gologin = new GoLogin({
  profileName: 'scraper-01',
  proxy: {
    protocol: 'http', // or 'socks5'
    host: 'us.residential.proxy.com',
    port: 10000,
    username: 'user-session-abc123',
    password: 'password',
  },
});


const { browserWSEndpoint } = await gologin.start();

Rotating Proxies

import { GoLogin } from '@gologin/core';


// With residential rotating proxy
const gologin = new GoLogin({
  profileName: 'scraper-rotating',
  proxy: {
    protocol: 'http',
    host: 'gate.smartproxy.com',
    port: 10000,
    username: 'user-rotate-session',
    password: 'password',
  },
});


// Each request gets new IP automatically

Sticky Sessions

// For multi-page flows (checkout, login, etc.)
const gologin = new GoLogin({
  profileName: 'account-manager',
  proxy: {
    protocol: 'http',
    host: 'gate.smartproxy.com',
    port: 10001, // Sticky port
    username: 'user-session-fixed123', // Session ID in username
    password: 'password',
  },
});


// Same IP for entire session

Proxy Rotation Strategy

// Rotate proxies at profile level
const proxyPool = [
  { host: 'proxy1.com', port: 8080, username: 'u1', password: 'p1' },
  { host: 'proxy2.com', port: 8080, username: 'u2', password: 'p2' },
  { host: 'proxy3.com', port: 8080, username: 'u3', password: 'p3' },
];


async function scrapeWithRotation(urls: string[]) {
  for (let i = 0; i < urls.length; i++) {
    const proxy = proxyPool[i % proxyPool.length];


    const gologin = new GoLogin({
      profileName: `scraper-${i}`,
      proxy: {
        protocol: 'http',
        ...proxy,
      },
    });


    const { browserWSEndpoint } = await gologin.start();
    // ... scrape url ...
    await gologin.stop();
  }
}

Best Practices

1. Match Proxy to Fingerprint

If your fingerprint says you’re in New York, use a New York proxy:

const gologin = new GoLogin({
  profileName: 'ny-scraper',
  fingerprintOptions: {
    timezone: 'America/New_York',
    locale: 'en-US',
  },
  geolocation: {
    latitude: 40.7128,
    longitude: -74.0060,
    timezone: 'America/New_York',
  },
  proxy: {
    host: 'us-ny.proxy.com', // NY proxy
    // ...
  },
});

2. Use the Right Type for the Job

TaskRecommended Proxy
Price monitoring (lenient sites)Datacenter
E-commerce scrapingResidential
Social media automationISP or Mobile
Account managementISP (static)
High-volume, tolerant targetsDatacenter
Sneaker/ticket botsMobile

3. Don’t Over-Rotate

More rotation isn’t always better:

// BAD: New IP every request
for (const url of urls) {
  await rotateProxy();
  await scrape(url);
}


// GOOD: New IP every session (50-100 pages)
let pageCount = 0;
for (const url of urls) {
  if (pageCount >= 50) {
    await rotateProxy();
    pageCount = 0;
  }
  await scrape(url);
  pageCount++;
}

Frequent IP changes look suspicious. Real users don’t change IPs mid-session.

4. Monitor Proxy Quality

async function checkProxy(proxy: ProxyConfig): Promise<boolean> {
  try {
    const response = await fetch('https://httpbin.org/ip', {
      agent: new HttpsProxyAgent(`http://${proxy.username}:${proxy.password}@${proxy.host}:${proxy.port}`),
      timeout: 10000,
    });


    if (!response.ok) return false;


    const data = await response.json();
    console.log(`Proxy IP: ${data.origin}`);


    // Check IP quality
    const quality = await fetch(`https://ipqualityscore.com/api/json/ip/${API_KEY}/${data.origin}`);
    const qualityData = await quality.json();


    return qualityData.fraud_score < 75;
  } catch {
    return false;
  }
}

Frequently Asked Questions

Can websites detect that I’m using a proxy?

Yes, but it depends on the proxy type and their detection sophistication.

Datacenter proxies:

// Websites can easily detect datacenter proxies
const detection = {
  ipLookup: '99.8% accuracy', // MaxMind, IPQualityScore databases
  asNumber: 'AWS: 16509, Google: 15169, Azure: 8075',
  organization: 'Amazon Technologies Inc.',
  connectionType: 'Data Center/Web Hosting/Transit',
  blacklists: 'Most commercial blacklists include these'
};

Residential proxies:

// Much harder to detect
const detection = {
  ipLookup: '95% pass basic checks', // Look like regular homes
  asNumber: 'ISP ranges (Comcast: 7922, Verizon: 7018)',
  organization: 'Comcast Cable Communications LLC',
  connectionType: 'Residential',
  blacklists: 'Rarely listed unless abused'
};

Advanced detection methods:

  • Traffic analysis: Unhuman request patterns
  • TLS fingerprinting: Mismatch between IP and browser
  • WebRTC leaks: Real IP exposure
  • DNS leaks: DNS requests bypassing proxy
  • Behavioral patterns: Too-fast, too-perfect actions

The reality: Good proxies + good fingerprints = 95%+ success rate. Bad proxies = instant blocks regardless of everything else.

How do I know if my proxy is working properly?

Test before you scale. Always verify your proxy configuration.

Basic connectivity test:

async function testProxy(proxyConfig) {
  try {
    const response = await fetch('https://httpbin.org/ip', {
      agent: new HttpsProxyAgent(
        `http://${proxyConfig.username}:${proxyConfig.password}@${proxyConfig.host}:${proxyConfig.port}`
      ),
      timeout: 10000
    });


    const data = await response.json();
    console.log(`Proxy working, IP: ${data.origin}`);
    return true;
  } catch (error) {
    console.error('Proxy failed:', error.message);
    return false;
  }
}

Quality assessment:

async function checkProxyQuality(proxyIP) {
  // Check IP reputation
  const qualityResponse = await fetch(`https://ipqualityscore.com/api/json/ip/${API_KEY}/${proxyIP}`);
  const qualityData = await qualityResponse.json();


  return {
    fraudScore: qualityData.fraud_score,        // 0-100, lower is better
    isProxy: qualityData.proxy,                  // Should match your proxy type
    isVPN: qualityData.vpn,                      // Should be false for residential
    isTor: qualityData.tor,                      // Should be false
    recentAbuse: qualityData.recent_abuse,       // Should be low
    country: qualityData.country_code,           // Match with expected location
    ASN: qualityData.isp                         // Should be residential ISP
  };
}

Warning signs of bad proxies:

  • High fraud scores (>75)
  • Listed as proxy/VPN when expecting residential
  • Recent abuse history
  • Wrong country/ISP combination
  • Slow response times (>5 seconds)

Why are residential proxies so much more expensive?

Simple economics - supply and demand plus infrastructure costs.

Datacenter proxy economics:

const datacenterCosts = {
  infrastructure: '$50-200/month per server',
  ipsPerServer: '100-500 IPs',
  monthlyCostPerIP: '$0.10-2',
  overhead: 'Low (automated management)',
  bandwidth: '$0.01-0.05 per GB',
  totalCost: '$0.50-2 per GB'
};

Residential proxy economics:

const residentialCosts = {
  userCompensation: '$5-20 per month per user',
  infrastructure: '$100-500/month per region',
  ipPerUser: '1-2 IPs',
  monthlyCostPerIP: '$5-20',
  overhead: 'High (support, compliance, legal)',
  bandwidth: '$2-5 per GB',
  legalCompliance: '$1-3 per GB',
  totalCost: '$3-15 per GB'
};

The expensive part: Getting legitimate residential IP addresses requires:

  • User compensation: Paying people to share their connection
  • Legal compliance: GDPR, CCPA, consent management
  • Support infrastructure: Managing millions of consumer connections
  • Liability insurance: Risk management for user misuse
  • Revenue sharing: Partner apps, SDK integrations

Why it’s worth it: Residential proxies have 5-10x higher success rates on protected sites. The cost per successful page view is often lower than cheap datacenter proxies.

Generally no for legitimate use cases, but context matters.

Legal uses (low risk):

  • Market research and price monitoring
  • SEO rank tracking
  • Ad verification
  • Security testing (with permission)
  • Academic research
  • Business intelligence

Gray areas (moderate risk):

  • Aggressive scraping against ToS
  • Competitive data collection
  • Automated account management
  • High-frequency data collection

Potentially illegal (high risk):

  • Fraud, identity theft, or scams
  • Circumventing security for malicious purposes
  • Harassment or spam campaigns
  • Accessing restricted/copyrighted content
  • Bypassing paywalls or DRM

Legal considerations:

const legalFactors = {
  termsOfService: 'Most scraping violates ToS (civil issue, not criminal)',
  dataPrivacy: 'GDPR applies if collecting personal data',
  computerFraud: 'CFAA applies if bypassing authentication',
  copyright: 'DMCA applies if reproducing protected content',
  consent: 'Residential proxy user consent varies by provider'
};

Best practices:

  • Respect robots.txt and rate limits
  • Don’t access data behind authentication without permission
  • Collect only necessary data
  • Implement proper data security
  • Consult legal counsel for commercial operations

Reality check: Thousands of companies scrape daily with residential proxies. Legal issues typically arise from harassment, fraud, or massive copyright infringement - not legitimate business intelligence gathering.

Should I rotate proxies for every request?

No! This is a common mistake that actually makes detection easier.

Why over-rotating is bad:

const suspiciousPatterns = {
  tooManyIPs: '1000 requests from 1000 IPs in 1 minute = bot network',
  sessionLength: 'Real users don't change IP every 30 seconds',
  geographicJumps: 'NY → LA → London → NY in 5 minutes = impossible',
  browserFingerprint: 'Same fingerprint, different IP = proxy rotation'
};

Real user behavior:

// Real human browsing patterns
const humanBehavior = {
  sessionLength: '2-60 minutes per session',
  requestsPerMinute: '5-30 requests per minute',
  ipConsistency: 'Same IP throughout session',
  breaks: 'Natural pauses between actions',
  geographic: 'Stays in same geographic area'
};

Recommended rotation strategy:

const optimalStrategy = {
  // Session-based rotation (50-100 pages per IP)
  pagesPerSession: 50,
  requestsPerMinute: 10,
  sessionDuration: '5-10 minutes',


  // Then rotate with delay
  delayBetweenSessions: '1-5 minutes',
  differentGeography: 'Different ISP/city if possible',


  // For high-risk sites
  conservativeApproach: '20-30 pages per session',
  extendedDelay: '10-30 minutes between rotations'
};

The sweet spot: Rotate every 50-100 pages or every 5-10 minutes of activity. This mimics real user sessions while maintaining IP diversity.

What about free proxies? Are they safe?

Absolutely not for serious work. Free proxies are dangerous and ineffective.

Where free proxies come from:

const freeProxySources = {
  hackedServers: 'Compromised servers repurposed as proxies',
  malware: 'Infected computers used without owner consent',
  honeypots: 'Security researchers monitoring traffic',
  dataCollection: 'Services selling your browsing data',
  unstableConnections: 'Abandoned hobbyist projects'
};

The risks:

const dangers = {
  security: 'They can intercept HTTPS traffic (MITM attacks)',
  privacy: 'All your requests logged and potentially sold',
  reliability: '95% uptime if you\'re lucky, usually &lt;50%',
  performance: 'Slow, overloaded connections',
  maliciousInjection: 'Crypto miners, malware, ads injection',
  ipReputation: 'Most are already blacklisted everywhere',
  legal: 'May involve illegal infrastructure use'
};

Real-world example:

const freeProxyReality = {
  successRate: '5-10% of requests actually work',
  blockRate: '90-95% immediately blocked by sites',
  dataRisk: 'Your authentication cookies stolen',
  bandwidthRisk: 'Your bandwidth sold to others',
  legalRisk: 'Potentially accessing through stolen infrastructure'
};

Cost comparison:

const costs = {
  freeProxy: 'Free up front, $10,000+ in data breach costs',
  cheapProxy: '$5/month, still blocked everywhere',
  qualityProxy: '$50-100/month, actually works',
  expensiveProxy: '$500-1000/month, maximum reliability'
};

My recommendation: If you can’t afford proper proxies, you can’t afford the consequences of using free ones. It’s cheaper to pay for quality than to clean up a security breach.

How do I choose a proxy provider?

This is critical - provider quality matters more than proxy type.

Evaluation criteria:

const providerChecklist = {
  reputation: '5+ years in business, good reviews',
  transparency: 'Clear sourcing and legal compliance',
  performance: '99%+ uptime, &lt;100ms latency',
  support: '24/7 technical support, response &lt;1 hour',
  compliance: 'GDPR, CCPA compliant privacy policy',
  trial: 'Free trial or money-back guarantee',
  documentation: 'Clear setup guides and API docs',
  scalability: 'Can handle your volume requirements'
};

Red flags to avoid:

const warningSigns = {
  tooGoodToBeTrue: '$1/month for unlimited residential proxies',
  noLegalInfo: 'No company information or privacy policy',
  paymentOnly: 'Accepts only cryptocurrency, no business registration',
  badReviews: 'Multiple recent complaints on review sites',
  unresponsive: 'No response to sales inquiries',
  vagueSourcing: 'Magical "millions of IPs" without explanation',
  noTrial: 'No way to test before commitment'
};

Top-tier providers ( 2026):

  • Bright Data: Industry leader, expensive but reliable
  • Oxylabs: Enterprise-focused, great documentation
  • Smartproxy: Good balance of price and quality
  • IPRoyal: Competitive pricing, decent performance

Mid-tier providers:

  • Proxy-Seller: Budget-friendly with basic features
  • Proxy-Cheap: Very cheap, but quality varies
  • StormProxies: Good for specific use cases

My advice: Start with a small trial package. Test extensively against your target sites. Only scale up after verifying success rates and performance.

Key Takeaways

  1. Proxy type matters more than you think — The wrong type gets you blocked regardless of fingerprint quality.

  2. Datacenter isn’t dead — For tolerant targets, it’s still the cost-effective choice.

  3. Residential is the default — When in doubt, use residential for detection-sensitive sites.

  4. ISP proxies are underrated — Best for account management and long sessions.

  5. Mobile is the last resort — Expensive but nearly unblockable.

  6. Match everything — Proxy location should match fingerprint location.

  7. Quality over quantity — A good proxy provider matters more than the cheapest price.

Next Steps

Proxy Integration Guide

Complete guide to configuring proxies with GoLogin. Proxy Setup →

Bypass Cloudflare

Combine proxies with fingerprinting to bypass Cloudflare. Bypass Guide →

Multi-Account Management

Use proxies for managing multiple accounts safely. Multi-Account →

Proxy Tester Tool

Test your proxy configuration before deploying. Proxy Tester →